Neil then mentions that The Protagonist may be the first person in history to get hypothermia from an explosion. Since the future has access to all of Sator's records at once (ex: Sator typing a message, waiting five days, and then typing another isn't going to affect which one the future sees first - they'll all just show up at once), then how do they actually communicate at all? This diagram is the best/only drawing I could find on the internet depicting the path of the inverted gold. It only takes a minute to sign up. So my question is, was the initial Goya drawing that fooled Kat also a plant by The Protagonist just to establish the toxic relationship between her and Sator? Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Sator: When I'm done, life continues. They have no choice but to turn back. If removing gold from the first capsule caused a paradox - then removing gold from any other capsule would have done, too. But it works only so far. Nolan in an earlier interview to Entertainment Weekly, The Los Angeles Times spoke with Claudia De Rham, Tenet movie review: Christopher Nolans new film is underwhelming and overwhelming at the same time, but not worth risking your life for, Karnataka elections: In Belagavi, Congress, BJP eye key Panchamasali votes, UPPSC initiative: Plans afoot for offering pvt jobs to PCS aspirants who fail to clear interview round, Prominent mutts poll sway under lens as key seer face rape charges, Punjab: Accused in Morinda sacrilege case dies in custody, Royal scandal alert: Prince Harry left out as Meghan Markle signs deal with WME talent agency, Congress, BJP eye key Panchamasali votes in Karnataka elections, Hisar schoolteacher stabbed inside classroom by 3 juveniles, With promises of UCC, NRC in Karnataka, BJP repeats template from Uttarakhand, Gujarat, UP, Mercury drops as rains lash parts of Punjab, Haryana, Ex-DGP Chattopadhyaya chargesheeted for providing security to PO in rape case. This is known as The Grandfather Paradox and is mentioned in the film. If commutes with all generators, then Casimir operator? What's the cheapest way to buy out a sibling's share of our parents house if I have no cash and want to pay less than the appraised value? Of course, Sator wouldnt be able to use that first stash of gold since he needs to re-bury it. It requires us to imagine information Nolan didn't actually show us: What if the box that young Sator dug up came equipped with its own mini-turnstile? How does Sator get the algorithm after the car chase? Now that I think of it, the people from the future could have burried a complete working turnstile. The tenet universe follows a "block universe" model, a.k.a, "What's happened, happened." If total energies differ across different software, how do I decide which software to use? Unbeknownst to him he is actually hanging out with the 'future' Kat who knows his plans and is attempting to keep him alive long enough to prevent the activation of The Algorithm. Is there any known 80-bit collision attack? There is however a solution to this paradox: But how did this work for the original cache of gold Sator found in Stalsk-12? 6+ Thoughts I Had Watching When Harry Met Sally For The First Time, The Voices Niall Horan Says Meeting Blake Shelton Was Fate, Reveals How Theyre Already Hanging Out Beyond The Show. Despite not knowing he constantly goes to bat for her. It's my opinion--backed up from the script, though there are minor inconsistencies between that script and the film as shot--that those other answers you mentioned ignore key elements of the film in pursuit of their own interpretations. Priya implies that Sator talks to the future by leaving digital records, such as audio recordings or documents. In the Tenet movie, Sator is shown to receive gold shipments from the future. Where is Sator between the Vietnam Yacht and Italy? The Los Angeles Times spoke with Claudia De Rham, a theoretical physicist from Imperial College London, and asked her if the science in the film holds up. Another not-so-big surprise from Tenet and director Christopher Nolan is the amount of questions we had after catching the film on the big screen. Expect views, reviews and news. Sator wishes to bring an end to everything as he has terminal pancreatic cancer, and believes if he has to die, then everything should die with him. In Tenet, how is this character able to retrieve the original cache of buried gold? Ralisation Bexter. He was a Russian oligarch used by future generations Be safe. Protagonist: But not you. This comes again in the grandfather paradox conversation, too. The "choice" alluded to by Kat is a reflection of Sator's perception of his own agency; it is notable that he is also said to be a madman. She killed him. It is not sure if Sator even knows how to trigger or detonate the algorithm. Rotas is also the name of one of Sators companies. According to Empire, Its a time-bending tactical technique for missions: you approach it moving forward in time, and then also approach it in reverse moving backwards from the future each side using the knowledge that the other side gained from having already experienced it. Starring John David Washington, Robert Pattinson, Elizabeth Debicki, Dimple Kapadia, Michael Caine, Kenneth Branagh and others, Tenet is Nolans take on an old-school spy thriller, with his own science-fiction spin. Embedded hyperlinks in a thesis or research paper. What you realize then is that in the future, that gold bar was inverted and traveled back through time in an unusual way, passing through The Protagonists hands, and never made it into the capsule until the moment when that henchman had tried to steal it. If so, how was it inverted? Instructions are to press a button on the side, and boom! She "knew" that the Protagonist and team would still be able to find a way to lift the algorithm from the dead drop location. How the heck did he know the code? Sator is okay with this because he has a terminal disease and doesnt want the world to live on after him. The Sator In a film that has very little emotional investment my question is why? Compared to previous movies, like Interstellar, the gap is maybe bigger. You jumped the gun! The same sunshine we basked in will warm the faces of our descendants' generations to come. Conseils He buries a capsule, transmits the coordinates (presumably via a hidden newspaper message or an equivalent), then digs it out and retrieves the inverted gold that was inserted there by future humans. Nothing happens on Sator's death, it doesn't even trigger the explosion which would've buried the time capsule. When the credits rolled and Travis Scott's The Plan started playing, I had a lot of questions going through my head, obviously. Nolan is a known fan twist endings, non-linear story telling and generally just making his audience say "huh?". The question is: will deleting the past erase all the damage done to the earth and fix their situation in the future? The mission: prevent Andrei Sator, a renegade Russian oligarch with precognition abilities, from starting World War III. Protagonist: Dead drops. An unknown agency is working with Sator to kill everyone in the past, because they're responsible. To do this they have to bust into an ultra secure free port. The Protagonist throws the bag of bombs away and the people are saved. Perhaps one of those hijinks is planting not just a second Goya, but also the first under the pseudonym Arepo? Nolan in an earlier interview to Entertainment Weekly had said, This film is not a time-travel film. In fact, it would make for a pretty clever temporal pincer movement. Scan this QR code to download the app now. But is this the first generation war or does The Protagonist need to go further and further back to prevent the meddling of the future in his own generation? Are we talking stock tips? The reversed car that crashed on the highway and burned, how long will the wreck lie there (or has been lying there in forward time) without anyone calling the police. Was there some tom foolery done by someone ahead of time to a combination that The Protagonist would have guessed first? Sator digs it up and keeps it for a year, at which point the gold's trajectory breaks down completely as its supposed to be put into the ground on December 31st but in actuality its been melted down and used for other purposes. I'm starting to confuse myself again. I knew you'd find a way. During the break in The Protagonist breaks a lock pick off inside of one of the doors, presumably a death sentence in this situation. Finally, it goes back underground when the bulldozer goes in reverse. Why typically people don't use biases in attention mechanism? escapades he must go on to prevent the Algorithm it's definitely a possibility. Its far less grounded into physics. WebThe tech has been monopolised in the future by a Russian oligarch named Andrei Sator, who has created an algorithm that allows him to invert his entropy, via turnstiles. In a twilight world of international espionage, an unnamed CIA operative, known as The Protagonist, is recruited by a mysterious organization called Tenet to participate in a global assignment that unfolds beyond real time. Ives: She jumped the gun. To get closer to Sator and keep a promise to Kat The Protagonist promises to destroy the fake Goya drawing that he holds above her head. Here's What Jay Hernandez Told Us, Viral TikTok Of Kid Adorably Singing Jack Blacks Peaches Has Me Thinking The Super Mario Bros. Song Might Be The New Let It Go, 10 Best Kellyoke Covers From The Kelly Clarkson Show, Who Should Replace Henry Cavill As Superman? For forward people, the inverted gold does not follow the same thermodynamics as normal gold, so it cannot be melted and used for other purposes. That only works if the present doesn't know the location, @ShayanRC the algorithm would indeed travel to the future "instantly" (from the future's perspective). Gold is great and all. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Sator (who is financed and guided by the future) detonating the algorithm in his present does not make sense if the main goal of the people in the future is to save their own world. At one point in Tenet Andrei Sator, played by Kenneth Branagh, tells The Protagonist that this whole mess was started because of the future generation's desire to eliminate the past (and a scientist in the future invented time travel). She's killed him. I'll be sure to keep my eyes peeled for sharp dressed background characters in my next viewing. Rseau Galavanting around with Neil in the past? My question is what else was in those little inverted time capsules, outside of gold, pieces of the Algorithm and assembly instructions? If they dug it up using heavy earth moving equipment after the explosion was triggered, the people from the future can't find it and detonate it. What were the most popular text editors for MS-DOS in the 1980s? Except, both sides are actually experiencing it simultaneously.. The fuse goes off because of Sator's death, but the algorithm is out of its casing and therefore is not triggered. But only when he was diagnosed with inoperable pancreatic cancer did he decide to fulfill the wishes of the future generation and assemble the Algorithm, end his life and the rest of humanity, on his own terms. Surely the future knows that their plan fails, since they send the Stalsk-12 time capsule for young Sator and don't instantly receive results (plutonium explosion in the sinkhole). Why? There is no paradox as far as the rules of the Tenet universe are concerned. You could also imagine that README file from the future was dumbed down to account for only components and technology readily available at the end of the 20th century. We learn that Sator communicates with people from the future and, as a result, gets an advantage in terms of information. Why isn't Sator 2 (inverted Sator) wearing an oxygen mask when he goes back to his yacht in Vietnam for his final moment? It is necessary for the plot, intuitively it is a possiblility that time reversal gives, but if you think of it enough you see that it cannot work. I understand that Kat is the only one close enough to Sator to fool him in the end but there is no possible way that The Protagonist knew she was that important at the beginning. Watch the Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny trailer for the upcoming Indiana Jones movie, opening in theaters on June 30, 2023.Harrison Ford returns as the legendary hero archaeologist in the highly anticipated fifth installment in the iconic Indiana Jones movie franchise. Does this create paradox every time someone stumbles on some random inverted stuff? Don't you see? Bringing death to all, because You can figure it out by thinking of how that inverted gold bar gets to the future (not in the capsule). The film never gives us a chance to see their emotional feelings for each other. 03 88 01 24 00, U2PPP "La Mignerau" 21320 POUILLY EN AUXOIS Tl. bomb detonation was triggered by this timer. You see the gold fall out of Sators hand since the scene is moving backwards. If total energies differ across different software, how do I decide which software to use? First, look at this from Sator's perspective: when he digs the ground to retrieve the gold, the gold was already present in the ground in his past. He recruited himself for the mission. What Shows Have Been Renewed or Canceled. brought me here. Protagonist: What's more fanatical than trying to destroy the world? What is a temporal pincer, you ask? Infos Utiles Many of them we've gone over already but none of them were as fascinating to me as 'Where was the 'future' version of The Protagonist' the entire time'? We already know that The Protagonist used a fake Francisco Goya drawing to meet with Kat and ultimately get close to her husband, Sator. The main part of the operation is the temporal pincer to lift the algorithm from the dead drop location. Protagonist: [Talking about Sator] He can communicate with the future? James Gunn Shares What Hes Looking For, Simon Pegg, Pom Klementieff And More Reach Out As Christopher McQuarrie Gets Mission: Impossible 7 In The Can 3 Years (And Millions Of Extra Dollars) Later, Ahead Of The Equalizer's Return, Actress Lorraine Toussaint Shares What She's Proud Of After Three Seasons. Hi Zonker, do you have any sources to back your theory up? Kat failed to prevent Sator from dying (and actually caused his death herself), but the algorithm didn't trigger or activate. The past (Sator's future) trajectory of that reversed gold bar goes from hand to hand until Sator buries it in the ground. If you send enough of it back the man is sure to be rich but to become a billionaire is a whole other level. But the algorithm (which is the fuel for the neuclear explosion) has been extracted safely, just in time, so it's not triggered. The rule of the tenet universe prevents it. Neil: It'll be linked Since the Tenet team was able to lift the algorithm from the dead drop location, even if the dead drop location has been sent to posterity, it can not be triggered (because it's not there anymore). The film makes it all clear that the Future has identified Sator as the man to end the world in his time. Maybe oil field locations? It really must be an inverted person digging it up and taking it through a turnstile. You may recognize Sator as the surname of Kenneth Branagh's Russian villain, Andrei Sator. A Tenet member would not need the capacity to make tough choices, they can just receive the objectively correct course of action to follow from the future. I agree with the eternal conflict of present vs the future, and the future has to get lucky only once, but changing perspective from present to the future doesnt make the time capsule appear in the future. The contraption is like any nuclear bomb, there is an initial fuse triggering the nuclear reaction causing the massive explosion. Unfortunately for the future generation, there's no way to answer that question because it's a paradox. Its future is rev2023.5.1.43404. What is this brick with a round back and a stud on the side used for? Neil: How? So in this way Stator leaves the original inverted gold in place to preserve its chain of causation from the future, while simultaneously having regular gold available to him to buy all the necessary components for his first home-built turnstile. There is some element of science. Into tracksuits by Paulie Walnuts, the Criterion Channel and Robert Eggers. Is it possible that people in the past actually know more about inversion than people in the future, since the past was forced to use it to wage espionage and intelligence warfare? A scientist made this Do you know the answers to some of these questions? The only residue issue with this is that, even if buried, the algorithm could still be dug out and destroyed before the Future gets it, so why all the fuss at all. Tenet believes that Sators plan will come into effect on the 14th (the month is unspecified). We are told that you can never, under any circumstances interact with your past self, which is why The Protagonist wears special gear when inverting into the Goya heist. The trajectory of inverted stuff will appear weird to forward people, but from the perspective of inverted stuff (or inverted people), their journey makes perfect sense. The Tenet team would not be able to lift the algorithm from the dead drop location, because the algorithm was still inside the cavern / dead drop location when Kat killed Sator. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. But the minds behind activating the algorithm decided that it was worth the risk because they were screwed anyway. So where was he? My head hurts just rereading that sentence. Christopher Nolan's time traveling adventure Tenet, starring John David Washington, Robert Pattinson and Elizabeth Debicki, is now in theaters across the world. Not to get into a physics lesson, but inversion is this idea of material that has had its entropy inverted, so its running backwards through time, relative to us., Nolan consulted Nobel laureate Kip Thorne on Tenet -- Thorne also worked with the filmmaker on Interstellar -- but ended up relegating some of his suggestions. Which language's style guidelines should be used when writing code that is supposed to be called from another language? Rotas: As a verb, it means to turn or rotate, which is how the time inversion machine works in Tenet. He didn't have an inversion machine at the time, so he couldn't possibly travel back in time to retrieve the package. Bonus question: why was the gold brought to Sator by helicopter inverted, rather than normal, given the only possible mechanism for retrieving it? The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? Boolean algebra of the lattice of subspaces of a vector space? This is completely avoided if you dig it out in reversed mode and then invert the bar, as this way there's one consistent gold timeline. It just sends out the location of the dead drop (the buried capsule). WebYes. She was deeply hurt when Sator coerced her not to see Max again. What is Wario dropping at the end of Super Mario Land 2 and why? Protagonist: I'd like to say That you don't have to do this, Kat In fact, he couldn't retrieve any object sent from the future without creating a paradox, thus making it impossible for the interactions with the future to begin in earnest. And yet, this is not how Tenet functions at all. When a gnoll vampire assumes its hyena form, do its HP change? Politics & Policy | Christopher NolanS Tenet, Explained by The Sator The Protagonist will soon master the art of "time inversion" as a way of countering the threat that is to come. We only see big bulky turnstiles in the movie, because Stator needs those devices large enough to contain people and maybe even bigger objects. Tenet is the product of a different world than Interstellar. After having a near-death experience, an unnamed CIA operative, known as the Protagonist, is selected to join the ranks of the shadowy government organization called Tenet: a group tasked with ensuring the survival of the human race. from being buried in the hypocentre, one of the logical conditions for the "FutureErasesThePast" function to be called is not fulfilled. Despite its numerous delays due to the current COVID-19 crisis Tenet has seen a strong box office performance internationally and is getting some high praise from critics. rev2023.5.1.43404. This is considered by his wife, Kat, to be the last time he experienced Counting and finding real solutions of an equation. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. What I like about the diagram is that, after the empty capsule is buried, the next thing that happens is both regular gold and inverted gold suddenly come out of the turnstile much like The Protagonist and the inverted Protagonist suddenly coming out of the turnstile at the Oslo Freeport. Why was it important to stop the Algorithm from being dropped into the time capsule? Overall, there is no line of dialogue in the film that suggests that Sator is to be the one that detonates the algorithm. This Indiana Jones 5 trailer was revealed during Star Wars Celebration 2023. How did the car end up at the port after explosion in Tenet? What you described (inverting ourselves and then retrieve gold) is a mechanism to prevent the "supposed paradox." But what if a random person stumbled on the gold bars. Has the cause of a rocket failure ever been mis-identified, such that another launch failed due to the same problem? Sator is dying, and taking a chapter out of the Bond villain playbook, he plans to take the entire world down with him by attempting to reverse the arrow of time permanently, which means that rather than simply flowing backwards, the people in the future would be able to overwrite the past., The film concludes with a large scale action scene that unfolds both forwards and backwards, while parallel scenes involving past and future versions of the same characters play out. Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. A minor scale definition: am I missing something? De Rham also explained the concept of entropy. Sator even uses her as an emotional and physical hostage against The Protagonist. Have a theory that explains something I missed? Quietly watching in the background, only willing to step in if he had to? He gives one inverted gold bar to the Protagonist though, thus breaking it's time flow. If someone from the future inverted gold on Dec 31st and buried it, it is bound to happen. | | The diagram is confusing because it doesn't specify that. Why didn't the machine beep when Joker killed this person? He also, it would appear recruited himself, setting up the mission which he would recruit his past self into without knowing that the version of him the future is the one pulling all of the strings., His loop closed, Neil tells The Protagonist, Whats happened, happened, but instead that in the future the world was always safe because they had already gone into the past to make it so., Dedicated professionals who write about cinema and television in all their vibrancy. Currently this seems to be purely speculation, for which the Stack Exchange network is not the right format. Likewise, digging out things from the future doesn't work. When the car was blown up The Protagonist was inverted so the heat coming from the particles made him cold to the point of hypothermia, but how did the windows start to freeze? Thus Armageddon is avoided. But Sator couldn't have removed the original set of gold (or any other object) from it's capsule, as doing so would create a paradox? He does not know it for sure. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. @galacticninja I think "probably" is the keyword in what Neil said. Shortly after saving Kat, the Protagonist is kidnapped and taken to a warehouse that has a Turnstile inside of it. Acheter une piscine coque polyester pour mon jardin. Her husband now holds the mistake above her head and uses it to leverage access to her son. Kat ends up killing Sator just as The Protagonist and Neil are able to stop The Algorithm from going off. Their whole idea was to erase the past to save the future. Mahir: Ives, she's killed him. Protagonist: The fitness tracker he wears. Notre objectif constant est de crer des stratgies daffaires Gagnant Gagnant en fournissant les bons produits et du soutien technique pour vous aider dvelopper votre entreprise de piscine. The people in the future (posterity) are expecting Sator to send them the location of the assembled algorithm (inside the capsule / dead drop), so they could get it in the future and trigger it then. The unknown future agent knew Sator would be there to discover the buried and inverted cache. @MovieMe There is no "time and place" their world ends aside from the "sometime, somewhere" of the man the in crystalline tower. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Christopher Nolans Tenet finally landed in India this Friday, and while fans of the filmmaker have been waiting with bated breath to finally be able to experience his vision on the big screen, the response hasnt been unanimously positive. A helpful diagram of that process is found in the link below. The Protagonist has been the man in charge of Tenet all along. Sator's tracker will detonate a fuse which will trigger the algorithm and end of the world. What would be the point of inverting it one more time before bringing it to the yacht? Why pick the lock if you already know the codes? Sator: Somewhere, sometime, a man in a crystalline tower throws a switch and armageddon is both triggered and avoided. The caches that Sator retrieves are being inverted by an unknown agent in our future, and are placed in the ground while in the reverse timeflow to be uncovered in the past (our presents). Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. The future is not the ones who plan to trigger the algorithm, that would be pointless for them. Protagonist: Yeah, found a way*. Zack Snyder Pushes Back On The Idea That His Superman Was Angry, And Explains His True Goal With DCs Man Of Steel, Emma Watson Gets Candid About Stepping Away From Acting After Harry Potter, Little Women: I Wasnt Very Happy, Yes, Robert Pattinsons Batmobile Designers Busted Out The Pink Paint For Barbie Immediately After Wrapping On The DC Film, Khlo Kardashian Rocked Side Butt Cutouts After Sister Kim Surprised Her With A Trip To See Usher, The Daily Show's Roy Wood Jr. Roasted 'A-Holes' Tucker Carlson And Don Lemon At The White House Correspondent Dinner, To Celebrate His Return To The UK, Steve-O Dropped A Throwback Video Partying With Naked Women, Cruel Intentions Star Joshua Jackson Has A Very Specific Complaint About Some Hollywood Sex Scenes, Matthew Lawrence Alleges Turning Down Major Hollywood Director's Sexual Advances Lost Him A Marvel Role And More, Sydney Sweeney Rocked A Sheer White Skirt With Black Lingerie As Rumors Swirl About Her Rom-Com Co-Star Glen Powell, Will Magnum P.I. Win/win, right? He is later awakened inside a thermal blanket, saved by Neil and his crew. While one very long and convoluted (read subjective) answer is accepted, the other answers are in the exact opposite direction and have solid points too. That algorithm would have been buried in case. There is an odd way to understand it such that its time flow isnt broken. Adrei Sator rose to power because he discovered correspondence from the future alongside a hefty stash of gold. location of the dead drop, set to fire if his heart stops. New blog post from our CEO Prashanth: Community is the future of AI, Improving the copy in the close modal and post notices - 2023 edition. 2021 U2PPP U4PPP - It is In Kiev, Ukraine, an unnamed operative, The Protagonist (John David Washington), assists in a CIA assignment to foil an opera siege and retrieve a stolen cache of plutonium. Very late to the party, but being able to rewatch Tenet numerous times on HBOMax (with subtitles!) When Kat shoots Sator, why doesn't the algorithm detonate? However he does this for his own personal (monetary) The people in the future financed and guided Sator to find and reassemble the algorithm, not to trigger or activate it. Imagine an inverted henchman dug up the capsule and brought it immediately to the yacht. In the final scenes of Tenet it is revealed that all the good guys, even The Protagonist, were working for the 'future' version of The Protagonist all along.

Tarot Cards Associated With Norse Gods, Articles T